Reaction to the Hobby Lobby Decision: Two Truths and a Lie

The recent Supreme Court decision in favor of Hobby Lobby is a cultural lightning rod.  The ruling stands, silent and immovable, but the reaction to it has put on quite a show.

Rather than discuss the ruling (quite enough has been said about that already) I’d like to consider what we can learn from the electric reactions. They are very illuminating.

It’s a fatal blow to women’s rights! No – it’s a defense of religious freedomCrack! It’s anti-science!  It’s stupid!  Bam!  A for-profit company has no standing under RFRA!  (Suddenly we’re all experts on legal standing.) Hobby Lobby is  hypocritical Not so fast.  Smack!  More hypocrisy.  And its other side.

You might think that this opinion storm is more confusing than illuminating. It depends on what you’re looking for.

The Supreme Court ruling itself is worth a look. It’s the silent lightning rod.

Now for the two truths and a lie that I observe in the light show.

Truth #1:  Reactions often reveal more truth about the one reacting than about the issue in question.  Those who view cultural issues as right vs. left or smart vs. stupid or us vs. them tend to apply a collection of biases and stereotypes to their interpretations.  When this happens, the reaction is a projections of their own fears and caricature-like perceptions of the opposition.

Essayist Anais Nin astutely observed, “We don’t see things as they are, we see them as we are.” 

This Chicago Tribune article demonstrates my point.  The author accused Hobby Lobby of desiring to deny women of their power by limiting contraceptive choices.  She figured that they do this out of an adherence to a “zero sum fallacy” that she heard about from a conservative commentator on the Bill Maher show.  She made no attempt to justify a connection between Hobby Lobby, a desire to oppress women and the zero sum fallacy.

I don’t know how she arrived at her conclusion.  In some way it reflects her world view, the interpretive framework through which she sees things. It tells us something about her.

Truth #2:  Many reactions betray roots of fearI believe that escalating anger, disrespect, and polarization in our cultural discussions are expressions of fear.  Christians fear government infringement on their religious freedom; others fear that Christians want to limit their personal freedom.

Fear is a powerful emotion, and it’s easy to lose objectivity when we feel threatened.  Fear is also a useful tool for those whose political or ideological interests are well served by stirring up fear and suspicion.  So we fight each other, each of us thinking we’re the “good guys” fighting the “bad guys.”

And that is the lie.

The people who disagree with you are not your enemies.  (They may not understand this, but it’s true.)  They are often fearful and doing their best to cope in an increasingly stressful world.  Just like us.  Often we’re all being manipulated.

In my next post I’ll take a look at a biblical lightning rod event and do my best to suggest some helpful applications of these two truths and a lie.  For now, perhaps the following truth will be encouraging.

“There is no fear in love. But perfect love drives out fear…” 1 John 4:18

“For our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the powers of this dark world and against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realms. Therefore put on the full armor of God…”  Ephesians 6:12-13

 “The fear of the Lord leads to life; then one rests content, untouched by trouble.” Proverbs 19:23

How do you process highly charged cultural conversations?  Do you agree that  fear is behind some of the hostility and disrespect?  I’d love your thoughts on this!

About Judy

At heart I am a student of truth, an observer of culture, and a communicator. Jesus is my teacher and my Lord. In pursuit of these passions, I read as much as I can, serve as Teaching Director for a Community Bible Study group, and write a blog in an attempt to synthesize it all. I take great delight in my relationships with family and friends, and I also enjoy long walks, bike rides and cooking. And did I mention that I like to read?
Gallery | This entry was posted in Christian Life, Christian Witness, Communication, Culture, Current Events, Faith, Following Jesus, Government, Perspectives, Religion and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Reaction to the Hobby Lobby Decision: Two Truths and a Lie

  1. Pingback: Deconstructing Disasters Du Jour | Connecting Dots…to God

  2. pdsteggs says:

    Fear, indeed, drives most outbursts of contradiction and outrage. Fear of what? Fear of change. Fear of losing control might lead to the realization that we’re not in control of anything in the first place. Fear of being wrong – which implies that the other view is right. “Larry Who” is absolutely correct — Love – that is, love God and love neighbor – is the only way out of the fear-filled death spiral most/all of society/world is currently experiencing.

    • Judy says:

      Amen to that, Dan. It’s one thing to recognize all the fear that is at work in the world, but it’s quite another to figure out how to counter it. I’m pretty sure I am motivated by fear in ways that I don’t even realize. Yes, love is an antidote to fear. To your point about fear of losing control, I would add faith to the fear-fighting mix. If we really believe that God is who he says he is, then why are we afraid of anyone or anything else? In fact, we often believe in ourselves, our jobs, our bank accounts, our government, and/or a host of other objects that we think we can control. That is essentially idolatry. It is not easy to really trust God. In fact, most of us have never really done it. Well, I guess that’s enough for me! I almost wrote another post! Thanks for stopping by, Dan!

  3. Larry Who says:

    Fear is a driving factor behind most cultural events, as in a fear of loss of our rights or something like that. But another big problem is how we define what is “perfect love,” as in 1 John 4:18. Somehow, Christianity has allowed society and its world system to convince believers that perfect love resembles what Hollywood spews from its movies. Yet, that is an absolute lie. Perfect love is keeping God’s commandments and loving God (1 John 2:5). Until we believers return to that type of love, we will continue to resemble sheets hanging on a clothes lines, being blown by every cultural wind.

    • Judy says:

      Well said Larry. I have to agree that Christians, myself very much included, are far from showing perfect love to God or to each other. Your image of floppy bed sheets is sadly appropriate. Thanks for your always insightful thoughts!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s